Place which

Can someone please tell me why. Improve this question. Neither "where" nor "which" is needed. See english. I agree with J. Taylor and see no reason for the prepositional madness at, which, where and to below Add a comment. Active Oldest Votes. Here are examples of such constructions from published literature: It reminded her of the pansies that bloomed in her aunt's garden, where she visited last summer.

Discussion The choice of which, that , or no word vs where depends on whether visit is taken as a transitive or an intransitive verb. Analysis of the various options We have four options. The grammar of [2] is completely analogous to the grammar of [2a] We enjoyed the islands [where we slept last week].

The structure of [2] is indicated as follows: We enjoyed the islands i [ where i we visited last week]. CGEL says: A 'double-variable' representation of [3] is "She wanted to see house x ; she had grown up in x ": the "in" component is contributed by where together with its spatial location function, with the antecedent determining the value of the variable x.

Here are related examples of such usage from published literature: He had visited on the Island of Elba that was Napoleon's home during his exile. This is obtained from [4] by omitting the subordinator that. Improve this answer. I stopped actively reading after that—but what I glanced at looked good.

Thank you for such a detailed answer. JasonBassford Thanks! There is one place where I'm not completely sure, and that's whether the construction He had visited on the Island of Elba is acceptable. Indeed, the two examples I quote there are the only two I could find.

Visiting can be used intransitively. I believe that TextRanch can help me to improve my writing skill. Thanks a lot. I would have not seen the mistakes in the text I submitted otherwise. The editor pinpointed exactly the parts I was having trouble with. I love that by using TextRanch, I will be able to confidently write emails or anything business related and feel good about it.

Thank you for correcting me: ". You help me make it look so easy. You and your Team are great! Being human powered provides more linguistic nuance. Great on-the-fly service! Top Customer Service We are here to help. Satisfaction guaranteed! Sign up with Facebook Sign up with Google or Register with email. Password required. Already have an account? Register with Facebook Register with Google.

Register with Facebook Register with Google or Register with email. Already got an account? Login with Facebook Login with Google or Login with email. Ok, I'll check my email not your email? Update my email. Notify me with an Email Or wait in this page. Stay right here to see why human proofreaders beat computer checkers every time! Log in. Install the app. JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly. You should upgrade or use an alternative browser. A tennis court is a place where you can play tennis. A tennis court is a place you can play tennis in the. A movie theater is a place that plays movies.

A movie theater is a place where you can watch movies. A highway is where you can drive faster. Those are made by me ,Help me correct them. Thanks a lot.